IB History
  • Home
  • Glossary and Histography
    • The Cold War
  • The Cold War
    • Capitalism
    • Communism
    • Causes
    • Cold War in Asia
    • Course of the Cold War
    • End of the Cold War
    • Essays

Cold War in Asia

Lesson Objectives
To identify the causes of ideological conflict in Asia and to assess why the US policy of containment switched to Asia

To identify the causes and consequences of the Korean War and evaluate its impact on the Cold War.

​To analyse US containment policy in Asia and evaluate the reasons for its successes and failures

To analyse the War in Vietnam in order to evaluate the reasons for the failure of Containment


Key Features of the Cold War in Asia

Cold War in Asia
  • US Foreign Policy (1949-1950)
  • 1946: Kennan
  • NATO: Collective security
  • Autumn 1949: China fell to communism, USSR developed first atomic bomb
  • August 1949: atomic bomb developed by USSR
  • US Nuclear monopoly ended
  • New balance of power between the super powers
  • October 1st 1949: Mao Zedong declared the People's Republic of China
  • Chinese Civil War (1945-1949)
  • Dean Acheson, US Secretary of State
  • 1949: White Paper published- US were not to blame for communism in China
  • US blamed Truman’s government for not begin enough to stop Communism in Asia
  • The Red Scare: Senator Joseph McCarthy (Wisconsin) alleged the USSR were conspiring to play Communist sympathizers in key positions in the US
  • 'Anti-Red'
  • February 1950: Secretary of State Dean Acheson was forced to publically reconsider the White Paper- confront China and Mao as an enemy, didn't legitimize the new government
  • 1950: US National Security Council, NSC-68 - warned that all Communist movement were traced back to the USSR, 'global theme'
  • 'Monolithic' view of communism
  • 'Indefinite period of tension and danger'
  • Recommended $35-$50 billion
  • Encouraged military and economic aid
  • Revisionist historians- criticized US perception of Soviet intentions, rested of false premises, 'excuse' for expansionism
  • Truman feared of growing Asian powers- 'yellow peril'
  • 25 June 1950: Korean War, Communist North Korea invaded South Korea
  • North Korean attack- USSR expansionism, instructed by Stalin
  • NSC-68 had predicted correctly the spread of communism
  • Truman government forced to contain the Communist threat
 
Why did the USA policy of containment shift to Asia after 1949?
  • Worked in Europe
  • China turning Communist (1949)
  • Communist viewed as 'monolithic'
  • Revisionist- USA wanted to expand
  • Domestic Pressure- Red Scare
  • Korea War (1950)

Textbook Activities

Picture
Activity 1:
HUAC (House Un-American Activities Committee) and the Hollywood Ten
  • Investigated the Hollywood Film Industry
  • Conducted interviews with 41 'friendly witnesses' working in Hollywood, named 19 people- accused of having left-wing views
  • October 1947: Roy M Brewer was interviewed, claimed to know 13 writers and actors involved in Communist activities
  • The Hollywood Ten: refused to answer, plead the Fifth Amendment, found guilty of Contempt of Congress- sentenced to prison
 
Alger Hiss
  • Accused of espionage by Whittaker Chambers
  • 1943: Interviewed by the FBI and J. Edgar Hoover, not enough evidence to convict
  • March 1945: Chambers gave the FBI further details of Hiss' espionage
  • November 1946: FBI sent a report to James F. Byrnes (Secretary of State) that stated Hiss was likely to be a Soviet agent
  • Interviewed by D. M Ladd (FBI's Assistant Director)- denied any involvement with Communist
  • FBI restricted Hiss's access and wiretapped his office and home phones
  • 5 August 1948: Hiss testified before the HUAC, stated he was never apart of the Communist Party
  • May 1949: Evidence found that Hiss had retyped State Department documents, proof the documents were typed on his typewriter, handwriting matched his
  • November 1949: retried- witness comes forward claiming in 1936 she was told by Hiss that he wanted to recruit Noel Field
  • 25 January 1950: Hiss was found guilty, sentenced to 5 years
The Rosenberg's
  • Accused of being Communist spies
  • 6 March 1951: both began trial
  • Julius Rosenberg plead the Fifth Amendment when asked if he was a member of the Communist Party, 'felt that the Russians contributed the major share in destroy the Nazi Army'
  • Ethel Rosenberg: denied all activities of espionage, stated she never typed anything involving government secrets on her typewriter
  • Rosenberg's both found guilty- given the death penalty, death row for 26 months
  • 19 June 1953: Rosenberg's were executed
  • Shocked many as they were not found guilty of treason, protests took place as many did not believe there was enough evidence for the death penalty
 
Role of the FBI
  • John Edgar Hoover was the first Director of the FBI appointed director, influenced the Library of Congress by making a card index of left wing opponents
 
McCarran Act (1950)
  • Required the American Communist Party and other organizations to register withe the Attorney General, under supervision- not allowed to hide membership to the party
  • McCarran Act stated that it was unlawful to want to form a totalitarian dictatorship
  • President Truman stated the act 'would betray our finest traditions', enacted over his veto
 
Why was McCarthy finally discredited?
  • People feared openly criticizing McCarthy- fear of being accused of being a Communist
  • Senate investigation into McCarthy's claims- televised
  • McCarthy lost his chairmanship of the Government Committee on Operations of the Senate, no longer had power
  • Media lost interest in his Communist accusations and claims
 
Activity 2: What is the message of this cartoon regarding the impact of McCarthyism on American society?
The cartoon shows the Statue of Liberty, which is a representation of the US as a whole this implies the spread of McCarthyism across the US. The cloud is dark and large and this can symbolize gloom and sadness.
 
Activity 3: Read the extract from NSC-68, identify the key phrases in the document that help explain why LaFeber believe it to be one of the most important documents of the Cold War. Give your reasons for your choice.
'Strike out a bold and massive program of rebuilding the West's defensive potential to surpass that of the Soviet world'
It shows the US was willing to aid and support other countries and its superiority as a superpower. It also shows that the US perceives the USSR as a weaker force than them. 
 
'An immediate and large scale build-up in our military and general strength'
It shows that the US is a superpower and is more superior than other nations, belief they are stronger than others.
 
Activity 4:
What international considerations would have an influence on Truman's decision to become involved in the Korean War?
  • 1949: the USSR successfully tested its own atomic weapon
  • 1 October 1949: The People's Republic of China, defeat of the GMD
  • Communism in Eastern European nations- 'iron curtain'
 
What domestic considerations would have an influence on Truman's decision to become involved in the Korean War?
  • McCarthyism and the Red Scare
  • NSC-68
  • Reelection 

The Korean War

Causes and Consequence of the Korean War

Korean War
  • Started on 25 June 1950- 90,000 North Korean soldiers launched invasion on South Korea
  • Occurred during a time of debate over the future of the US foreign policy- many in Washington advocated a massive re-armament program to confront the Communist globally, NSC-68 (National Security Council Report)
  • President Truman realized that a failure to take action would undermine the credibility of the US policy of containment
  • US sent aid to South Korea, called on the United Nations to sanction military action against North Korea
  • 27 June 1950: Resolution sanctioning a UN-mission against North Korea
  • Security Council voted unanimously (without opposition), USSR was boycotting the Security Council of US refusal to recognize Communist China- did not vote
  • 1 July 1950: troops from US and 15 other nations arrived in Korea, led by UN Commander, General Douglas MacArthur (US)
  • US government accepted the recommendations of NSC-68, raise the military budget
  • Cold War became a global war- US sought to confront communism in Asia and Europe
  • Stage 1: North Korean Invasion- initial push by the North Koreans, resulted in the capturing of the entire Korean peninsula apart from small areas of South-East, city of Pusan
  • Stage 2: UN counter attack- MacArthur led UN forces on a assault in Inchon, hoping to split North Korean forces in half, within a month the UN had recaptured Seoul and driven the North Koreans past the 38th parallel, US decided on a policy of 'roll back' to cross the North Korean territory and reunite Korea
  • Pyongyang (North Korean capital) captured in October
  • Stage 3: Chinese counter-attack- MacArthur pushed to the border with China at the Yalu River, despite Chinese warnings
  • 27 November 1950: 200,000 Chinese and 150,000 North Korean troops counter attacked the UN, retreat of UN forces
  • December 1950: Pyongyang and North Korea was recaptured, UN forces suffered heavy causalities
  • Stage 4: War descended into a stalemate along the 38th parallel, Truman decided to revert to a policy of 'containment', MacArthur disagreed and threatened the use of atomic weapons against China, MacArthur was removed by Truman
  • 1951: peace talks
  • July 1953: signed a armistice at Panmunjom
 
Causes of the Korean War
Failure to unite Korea after WW2
  • 1945: agreed by the superpowers to temporarily divide Korea, joint responsibility for repatriating Japanese forces
  • 38th parallel was taken as dividing line with the USSR occupying the north and the USA and the south
  • December 1945: Council of Foreign Ministers' Moscow Conference, the USA and USSR agreed to create a provisional government in Korea- leading to independence
  • Independence was never achieved
  • Cold War developed the superpowers became less willing to cooperate
  • Moscow Agreement- separate government emerged on either side
  • South (US) appointed Syngman Rhee, anti-communist
  • North (USSR) Kim II Sung, communist
  • Both fought the Japanese, both wanted to end the division- different ideologies
  • Americans persuaded the UN to establish a commission to supervise Korean elections- it was refused entry
  • Americans persuaded the UN to establish a commission to supervise Korean elections- refused entry to the North
  • May 1948: elections held in South Korea
  • Republic of Korea- set up by Syngman Rhee, undemocratic and anticommunist, recognized as legitimate by the UN General Assembly
  • Democratic People's Republic of Korea- set up by Kim Il Sung (September 1948, recognized by the Communist Bloc
  • Failure to unify Korea- led to a permanent division of Korea, two hostile states

Textbook Activities

Picture
​Activity 5: What similarities and what differences are there in the way in which Germany and Korea each became divided into two separate countries?
 
Similarities
USSR and US supported one side of the divided country
Korea was split into two sections, unlike Germany which was split into four sections

Differences
USSR set up a Communist government, US set up a Democratic government
Korea had the involvement of neighboring countries, China and Japan


Activity 6:
John Lewis Gaddis suggest the Korean War could be called 'A Comedy of Error's', discuss what misconceptions guided the thinking of Truman, Stalin and Mao during the planning and course of the Korean War
Truman: Soviet 'sphere of influence' was spreading into Asia, direct result of Stalin
 
Stalin: Aimed to gain more territory, spread influence throughout Asia
 
Mao: Believed if China assisted the USSR would support them further, aiming to improve and gain superpower status
 
The initial crisis that followed the North Korean invasion of South as a Case Study in crisis, instead of suing the course of the war itself, focus on the crisis that led to the US-led UN force intervening
North Korea: aimed to control and defeat the South, resulting in the South fighting back- with the assistance of the UN (led by General MacArthur), resulting in a stalemate at the 38th parallel
 
Activity 7:
What is meant by the reference to using a 'roundish one'?
'Round'- the whole word, represents Marshalls attempt to gain a global view on foreign policy worldwide
 
What is the problem with using only a 'squarish one'?
'Square'- MacArthur targeting Asia as the Cold War spread globally, needed to take a less bias perspective and address the issue globally
 
Activity 8: How did can the Korean War be seen as a Civil War
The Korean War divided Korea into the North and South. They shared different ideologies as well as were supported by different countries (US and USSR). The war was fought internally between the two sides of Korea, it was mainly fought by Koreans but had foreign assistance on both sides.
 
Role of the USA
  • Korean peninsula, both superpowers began to withdraw their troops
  • 1948: Soviet troops left the North
  • Mid 1949: US troops left the South
  • January 1950: Dean Acheson's 'perimeter' speech, the US declared that they wouldn't commit troops in mainland Asia
  • Withdrawal of troops left a power vacuum in Korea- US declared that they wouldn't commit troops in mainland Asia
  • Withdrawal of troops left a power vacuum in Korea- hostilities between the two Koreas could develop, the withdraw of US troops
  • Presented Kim Il Sung with an opportunity
  • Both leaders wanted to reunify Korea on their own terms- ideology
  • Kim Il Sung tried to persuade Stalin into supporting an attack on the South, which he eventually agreed
  • Stalin wasn't to blame for the war, his support for Kim Il Sung was significant in the North's decision making
 
The Role of Stalin
  • Stalin was hopeful of winning
  • 1949: first atomic bomb, Chinese communist victory
  • Japan threatened Stalin's control in the region
  • Opportunity to spread communist influences
 
The Role of Mao Zedong
  • Kim Il Sung had the support of China
  • Mao was initially skeptical about the success of the invasion
  • Kim persuaded Mao that Stalin was more enthusiastic than he actually was- Mao was keen to gain support from Stalin for a planned attack on Taiwan
  • Mao gave his approval to Kim to an attempted invasion of the South
 
Effects on the USA
  • Korean war heightened US fears of further Soviet aggression elsewhere, the NSC-68 recommendations to triple the defense budget were approved
  • US land forces in Europe were strengthened along with NATO- added Greece, Turkey and West Germany
  • Plan had already been discussed before the war- severed as a catalyst for these policies
  • 1952: USA signed the Treaty of San Francisco with Japan, allowed the USA to build military bases and rapidly rebuild the economy
  • US began increasing its support for Chiang Kai-shek in Taiwan, isolate China
  • 1954: Southeast Asia Treaty Organization (SEATO), anti-communist containment bloc.
  • Members: Thailand, Philippines, Pakistan, USA, UK, France, Australia, New Zealand
 
Effects on Korea
  • War had cost the lives of over 300,000 civilian and property damage was huge, peninsula became permanently divided with no hope of reunification
  • 38th Parallel became a new heavily defended frontier in the Cold War that exist even today
  • North Korea remains under Communist rule while South Korea became a successful democratic and capitalist nation
 
Effects on China
  • China's reputation grew after the war, having successful pushed back US forces, increased Mao Zedong's reputation and helped him to consolidate the Communist revolution in China
  • Stalin' reluctance to help China throughout the war would eventually contribute to the divisions between the two powers- with China taking a more independent stance away from Moscow
  • Mao's aim of uniting Taiwan with China became harder as the USA now committed itself to defending Taiwan
 
Effects on the USSR
  • USSR was not directly involved in the Korean War, did give tacit consent to North Korea
  • Long term- the outcome of the war damaged Soviet interests, the USA's decision to triple its military spending, rearm West German, maintain troops in Europe and contain Communism in Asia, drew the USSR into a wider, global conflict
  • Stretch Soviet commitments throughout the world, harming their economy
 
Effects on Southeast Asia
  • Korean War was an attempt by the USA to contain communism in Asia, Asia was now a new battleground in the Cold War
  • Nationalist groups in countries like Vietnam, Cambodia, Malaysia and Philippines all sought independence from Colonial powers- some movements were communist and increasingly relied on USSR or China for support
  • US policies increasingly confused these national communist group as being allied with Moscow, eventually lead to the USA's involvement in Vietnam
 
Effect on the Cold War
  • Korean War effectively globalized the Cold War, no longer just a European conflict but a global conflict would also affect other parts of the world
  • Led to increasing militarization, both side increased their military budgets, with the USA's military budget, reaching 10% of GNP in the 1950s
  • USSR increased the size of the Red Army from 2.8 million troops to 5.8 million
Picture
Picture
Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Glossary and Histography
    • The Cold War
  • The Cold War
    • Capitalism
    • Communism
    • Causes
    • Cold War in Asia
    • Course of the Cold War
    • End of the Cold War
    • Essays